Both Blackboard and Moodle were similar. They have options to make discussion boards, quizzes, folders, and a nice calendar to post weekly assignments.
I think that I liked blackboard better. This is probably because I am a little more familiar with the program. I felt that it was very user friendly. I could easily play around with things on my own and not have to watch a tutorial to figure out how to create something. I felt like I got a little lost on Moodle. I had to watch a couple of tutorials to get me started. I think that I only scratched the surface on what I can do with Moodle.
There were a couple of things that I did on both programs so I could compare them. The first one was making a quiz. In blackboard all I had to do was go under the assignment heading and click on create assessment. I was then given several options of types of problems that I would want to create. It was also possible to upload a picture or use a link to ask questions on. The program could also grade the assessment for you. You just had to enter in the correct answer. It was also possible to give partial credit I saw on some types of problems. On Moodle you go under the weekly outline use the drop down menu for add an activity and choose quiz. It also gave you several types of questions you could use and you can upload a picture or use a link to ask questions on. The one thing I liked better about Moodle was the picture would show up in the quiz and you did not have to click on the link and wait for it to show up like on BB. Moodle also had an option to make the quiz timed and if you wanted to give the student a chance to change their answers with or without penalty of points. I thought that was pretty cool for an option.
The other item I checked out was making a discussion board. Both of them were easy to make. Blackboard already has an option for discussion board and you just make a title and add in your question. Moodle adds it in on the weekly outline. You again add a title and question for people to answer. It just adds onto what you already have in the weekly outline.
One cool thing I saw in BB was how easy it was to add a youtube video. I was under assignments and clicked on build content and saw youtube video under mash ups. I tried it and it adds in the video right into BB and not as a link. One thing I liked better about Moodle was that it lets us upload a picure to attach to our profile. I could not get mine to upload but I really like that idea. I like putting a face with a name.
In conclusion I liked BB better in designing an online class because I like its organization and it seems more user friendly to me. This may be because I have gotten used to using it but at the moment that is my opinion.
I like BB too. I think it is user friendly and it handles uploads way better. I tried to load a PPT on to Moodel and it failed 2 times so I just gave up.
ReplyDeleteFirst thing I thought of was money. If I understand it right, MOODLE is free. Don't we have to pay for BlackBoard services. They both hav a lot to offer. I think both would be better in the classroom than whay we have. SISK12 has too many glitches.I don't trust it. I'm always going bak to make ure the grades are in. Wasted time.
ReplyDeleteI liked how easy they are to build content, but I kinda liked the Moodle format where you did it in the calendar view better. Great post!
ReplyDeleteI agree with Ken, money is something to think about. I liked, and agreed with you, about putting a face with a name (regarding moodle). Some of us visual learnbers out there need this. Also, overall, I think Moodle is more visually appealing.
ReplyDeleteI am like you moare familiar with Blackboard
ReplyDeleteI agree with you there is just something about Blackboard that is much more user friendly than Moodle. Or your right it could also that we are just more familiar with it as you pointed out.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Michelle as well. I feel like BB is much easier to use. It seems like Moodle just had a lot going on for me. I like how structured BB seems.
ReplyDeleteI liked your math quiz and seeing how it responded to correct and incorrect answers.
ReplyDeleteMelissa,
ReplyDeleteI am more familiar with BB as well. I like the ease of moving throughout the tabs. I also like the fact that the setup would be the same for every class. With Moodle, I feel like I have to relearn how to use each class that I am enrolled in.
What a good idea, doing the same thing in both systems. I was too rushed and didn't get a good feel of how to utilize Moodle effectively. Great post!
ReplyDeleteGreat way of testing two systems - by doing the same things in both! I can see using any of them if I have to. While I am familiar with BB, using Moodle will be as good I think in terms of getting the materials to students and getting the assignments back. After working with BB for a few years I think they all have their pros and cons and as long as it works for what its intended then it's great :)
ReplyDelete